The main binding force in wet iron ore green pellets has been found to be the cohesive force of the viscous binder. The wet compression strength (wet-CS) in green pellets is, however, also influenced by the green pellet plasticity. A certain degree of plasticity is needed to sustain the green pellet growth rate. Too much plasticity results in decreased bed permeability and production problems. As the plasticity increases, wet-CS decreases. The amount of moisture needed to create a given degree of plasticity depends on particle properties and on the particle size distribution. Therefore, it was of interest to study how wet-CS would be influenced by variations in raw material fineness, if the green pellet plasticity was kept constant, i.e. the green pellet properties would be compared under relevant industrial balling conditions. For this purpose, magnetite concentrates of different particle size distributions were balled in a laboratory drum and the moisture content for constant plasticity was determined for each of the materials. No difference in green pellet wet-CS as a function of the raw material fineness was found when the bentonite binder was used and the plasticity was adjusted to a constant level. Green pellets prepared of raw materials with narrow size distributions were just as strong as those with broader ones. This is because the main binding force is the cohesive force of the viscous binder. In green pellets balled without the bentonite binder, wet-CS increased with increasing specific surface area in the raw material, in a similar manner as has been shown in earlier agglomeration literature. In this case, the capillary forces prevail. Comparison of wet-CS at constant moisture, instead of constant plasticity, would lead to erroneous conclusions. Fineness, or rather the slope of the particle size distribution curve, had a major impact on the moisture content needed for constant plasticity. If the slope increases, more water is needed to keep the plasticity on a constant level. Implications of these results in control of industrial iron ore balling circuits are discussed.