The focus of this essay is to develop a design concept for online public discussions with deep discussions and low information overload. The method used is Concept Driven Interaction Design (CDID) which involves constructing a design concept by applying a variety of theories in tangible interaction design. A design concept has three basic parts: a name, high-level goals and outlines generic principles. CDID includes seven steps which is used in this work:
1. Concept Generation – Formatted into a table that compare forum discussion (with several hypothesis) compared to discussions with the method Philosophy for Children (P4C) and other theories.
2. Concept Exploration – Eight distinct design aspects are identified from the comparison table.
3. Internal Concept Critique – The design aspects are compared to three similar discussion formats.
4. Design of Artifacts – Design concept version 1 is created.
5. External Design Critique – Interviews are conducted to explore their general experience of online discussions, investigate the hypothesis from the comparison table and to seek direct feedback on the first draft of the design concept.
6. Concept Revisited – Changes are made to the design concept based on the interview material and the direct feedback.
7. Concept Contextualization – The design concept is related to the original literature.
The result of the study is a design concept named CoFramer. CoFramer’s generic principles are summarized and contrasted against factors identified from the interview material in this table:
Tabell 2: CoFramer’s generic principles and interviews about online discussions.
CoFramer’s generic principles | From interview material on forum discussion
Organized start and ending | Discussions without clear ending
Limited number of participants | Large number of participants
Minimum number of participants | Large number of inactive spectators
Explicit participants | Low information about participants
Common conditions | Vagueness in participants conditions
Limited information density per post | Long posts and/or fast posts
The red thread and parallel threads | Often parallel threads
Active facilitator | Unresolved misunderstandings
The study indicates that CoFramer would create more structured discussions with a lower amount of information overload and less grounding cost compared what normally arise in public online discussions.