CO2 conversion plays an important role in mitigating the issues caused by CO2 emissions. Among different CO2 conversion technologies, CO2 electrochemical reduction (CO2R) is considered as one of the most promising ways, but it still suffers from high overpotential, low reaction rate, and low selectivity. Ionic liquids (ILs) and deep eutectic solvents (DESs), as novel solvents with many unique advantages, such as wide electrochemical window, high stability, and tunable nature, have been widely used as electrolytes for CO2R to reduce the overpotential and improve reaction performance. Currently, numerous studies on CO2R with IL/DES-based electrolytes have primarily focused on fundamental research, providing insights into CO2R performance improvement and reaction mechanism analysis, but research on evaluating the techno-economic and environmental feasibility of CO2R is very limited. Meanwhile, from an experimental viewpoint, how to further improve the performance of CO2R by designing/modifying catalysts and electrolytes is another concern.
This work aims to systematically study the techno-economic and environmental feasibility of the CO2R process under current and future conditions, along with technology development focused on designing novel catalysts and electrolytes for CO2R, where ILs/DESs were used as electrolytes. Since CO2 can be converted to different chemicals/fuels, such as CO, syngas, HCOOH, CH3OH, CH4, and some multi-carbon compounds. The research status, difficulties, as well as the future research focuses for producing different products need to be clear. To this end, a comprehensive literature survey was conducted to highlight recent progress, to offer an overview of the state-of-the-art advancements, and to identify research gaps in CO2R within IL-based systems. Based on the literature survey, CO, syngas, and CH3OH have been identified as particularly attractive products, considering both CO2R performance and the challenges associated with product separation.
Based on the results from the literature survey, a comprehensive assessment model for the integrated (CO2R + biomass gasification) process was established, enabling the evaluation of key performance parameters and commercialization potential for both stand-alone and combined processes. In terms of technology development, a molecule-regulated Ag catalyst was designed for CO2R in the IL-based system, where its reaction performance and mechanisms were thoroughly analyzed. Additionally, DES-based solvents were selected as electrolytes for CO2R with Ag as the catalyst, and the effect of electrolytes on CO2R performance was studied. The main results are summarized below.
The stand-alone CO2R process for producing CH3OH in IL-based electrolytes was first established and then further integrated with biomass gasification. The economic and environmental viability of these processes under current and future conditions was thoroughly examined. The high total production cost (TPC) of the stand-alone CO2R process is primarily driven by the significant expenses associated with the electrolyzer and electricity. After integration, TPC can be reduced from 1.44 to 1.02 €/kg-CH3OH. In the integrated process, electricity for CO2R constitutes the main portion of energy usage and is the predominant contributor to CO2 emissions.
A techno-economic analysis was conducted on the integrated processes of CO2R to CO/syngas/CH3OH, combined with biomass gasification for CH3OH production. Among these processes, the process combined with CO2R to CO showed the lowest TPC of 0.38 €/kg-CH3OH under current conditions, which is below the market price of CH3OH (0.50 €/kg-CH3OH). Sensitivity analysis revealed that electricity price is a crucial factor affecting TPC for all combined processes. In addition, CO2R performance and stack price significantly impact TPC in processes that involve CO2R to syngas and CH3OH.
Experimental research on CO2R to CO was conducted with a molecule-regulated catalyst in BmimPF6-based electrolytes. Specifically, the molecule with desirable CO2 affinity, 3-mercapto-1,2,4-triazole (m-Triz), was introduced onto the surface of Ag to obtain the Ag-m-Triz catalyst. This catalyst demonstrated desirable performance, achieving a partial CO current density of 85.0 mA/cm2 and a Faradaic efficiency of CO of 99.2% at -2.3 V vs. Ag/Ag+. Mechanism studies revealed that the enhanced performance is due to the increased CO2 adsorption ability and the reduced binding energy for the formation of the COOH* intermediate, resulting from the introduction of m-Triz on the surface of the Ag catalyst.
To investigate the effect of electrolytes on CO2R, a DES-based non-aqueous electrolyte, 0.5 M 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium chloride/ethylene glycol (BmimCl-EG) with a mole ratio of 1:2 in acetonitrile (AcN), was used as catholyte for CO2R to CO over Ag. The results showed that the highest Faradaic efficiency could reach 100% within the potential range of -2.0 to -2.4 V vs. Ag/Ag+, which is 1.43 times higher than the maximum Faradaic efficiency achieved in 0.5 M KHCO3. Additionally, the overpotential was reduced by 150 mV, and the current densities increased significantly across various applied potentials compared to the results obtained using 0.5 M BmimCl in AcN. In situ ATR-SEIRA measurements confirmed that EG, acting as a hydrogen bond donor, participated in the CO2R process, thereby enhancing the reaction performance.
Luleå: Luleå tekniska universitet, 2024.
CO2 electrochemical reduction, Ionic liquid, Deep eutectic solvent, Catalyst, Biomass gasification, Techno-economic analysis, Environmental assessment